'Can we forgive the pathologist who wrongly labelled a healthy person as a diabetic patient for receiving the favour of the referring physician and possibly for a few thousand rupees?'
'The delinquent homeopath who caused a cataract in a child by giving terribly wrong drug must go to jail.'
'How can we permit a gynaecologist to practice her/his specialty if s/he tinkers with the faith of the patient in an abhorrent way?'
'Paying money does not guarantee good healthcare. The private healthcare system largely treats patients as revenue generators,' crusading doctor Dr Arun Gadre tells Dr K S Parthasarathy.
We know that some medical policies and many medical practices in India are deeply flawed. We have heard of 'widespread examples of irrational drug prescribing, kickbacks for referrals, and unnecessary investigations and surgical procedures.'
However, the details revealed by Dr Arun Gadre, a gynaecologist from Maharashtra, in theBritish Medical Journal after interviewing 78 doctors from across India is very disturbing, shameful, and distressing.
The 'Personal View' in the journal reflects the conclusions in his Marathi book, Kaifiyat -- Pramanik Doctoranchi (Reflections by Sincere Doctors) based on the testimonies of these doctors.
This book went into two editions (September 2014 and October 2014). Dr Gadre may publish an English version shortly.
The book lists many malpractices. Some doctors get Rs 30,000 to Rs 40,000 for referring patients for angioplasty. Of the 150 doctors contacted, only three were willing to refer patients without kickbacks.
Another diabolic practice is followed by some gynaecologists. They perform ultrasounds without indications in pregnant women who complain of trivial abdominal pain, then fabricate false reports of cervical abnormalities and advice the women to have cervical stitches, with the pretext of preventing miscarriage!
Patients seldom go for a second opinion. The delinquent doctor does not give them any documents to avoid being found out.
Another tragic example is that of homeopaths who give little girls corticosteroids for red eyes; long term use lead to cataracts that required surgery.
Over prescription of a battery of tests is very common even when there is no suspicion of pathology. A shocking practice was what a pathologist referred to as the 'sink test'.
"Only a few of the tests are performed, and the extra blood collected is dumped in the sink. Fabricated results are given in the normal range for all tests that were not performed. The patient pays a large sum, which is shared by the referring doctor and the pathologist," Dr Gadre discovered.
In Maharashtra, many homeopaths and doctors trained in Ayurveda practice allopathy with the cursory knowledge imparted by medical representatives.
A few years ago I discovered that the young physicians taking care of heart patients in an ICU in Navi Mumbai were all fresh graduates in Ayurveda. Then they were working for a pittance; once their 'training' in such a hospital is over they can go back to locations outside the city and carry on allopathic practice legally.
Some pathologists label healthy persons as diabetic patients making them dependent on the referring doctor for life!
"These interviews indicated the alarming extent of the deterioration of rationality and ethics in India's private medical sector and the need for stringent, transparent, and mandatory regulation," Dr Gadre warned.
"These interviews underscore one fact -- paying money does not guarantee good healthcare. The private healthcare system largely treats patients as revenue generators, without rationality or medical logic," he added.
No comments:
Post a Comment